Honest Comparison

Kestrel vs Zillow Preferred fees

Zillow Preferred is paid at closing, as a percentage of your commission. That makes every lead you fumble expensive twice. Here is what the fee looks like in dollars, next to a flat $99.

KestrelZillow Preferred fees
How you pay$99/mo founding ($149 standard)A percentage of your commission, paid at closing
Who sets the rateFlat and published: $99 founding ($149 standard)Not one flat rate everywhere — confirm yours in your agreement
Illustrative fee on a $12,000 commission at 15%$0 at closing$1,800
Illustrative fee on a $12,000 commission at 25%$0 at closing$3,000
Illustrative fee on a $12,000 commission at 35%$0 at closing$4,200
Kestrel for a full year$1,188 ($99 × 12)n/a
One extra closing a year, net of the fee (35% case)$1,188 a year is the whole cost — Kestrel takes no cut of the deal$7,800 after the fee, before your brokerage split
Usage fees / contractNone — flat rate · None — cancel anytimePer your Preferred agreement
Replaces Zillow?No — it answers the leads Zillow sends—
60-second AI text response✓Your own follow-up speed
SMS qualification & lead scoring✓ HOT / WARM / COLD alerts—
Free trial14 days, no card required—

Run it with your own numbers

Type your average commission, the success fee percent in your agreement, and how many closings you expect. The math runs in your browser; nothing is sent or saved.

$4,200fee owed on one closing
$50,400fees across your closings in a year
$7,800what one extra closing nets you after the fee, before your brokerage split
$1,188Kestrel for a year at the founding $99/mo, so one extra closing covers it 6.6× over

Fee rows are illustrative: the 15%, 25% and 35% figures are examples on a $12,000 commission, not Zillow’s published rates. The 35% / $4,200 example and the caution that agents “should not assume that a single flat referral percentage applies everywhere” come from The Close’s coverage of Zillow Preferred; Preferred is invite-only and terms vary by agent and market, so check your own agreement. “Net of the fee” ignores brokerage splits and taxes. Zillow is a trademark of its owner; Kestrel is not affiliated with or endorsed by Zillow. Kestrel does not replace Zillow — it answers the leads Zillow sends in about 60 seconds, so the ones you already paid for do not go cold.

Already paying for the lead? Answer it in 60 seconds.

Live in two minutes. No contract, no setup fee, no card for the trial.

Start Your Free Trial